Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

Went on for too long

I enjoyed the first 3 attempts thinking that it would have a clever ending coming soon, but I was wrong. It came about 10 attempts later. Some of the attempts were funny, but others were just a waste of time and of an attempt.

Great remake of a Classic

Nice job. I liked the way you used the official cartoons for this.

Funny Usage of LotR Clips

Nice frames you used to show the expressions on their faces.

Gets boring after the first song

I got bored after the first song, yet I continued to play the rest of the songs so I could unlock the Bilbo Baggins song. The arrows landing on the circles was WAY off. You could hit the button late and still get a perfect.